Senior Partner Steven L. Duckett, Jr. explains how his investigation into a questionable chain of custody for a blood sample helped secure a favorable outcome for a client facing significant jail time for DUI.
Attorney: Steven L. Duckett, Jr.
Charge: Felony DUI, Sixth Offense
Outcome: Plea Agreement, 14 Months Active Incarceration
When a DUI case makes headlines, public opinion can form long before all the evidence has been examined. For one Battlefield Law Group client with multiple prior DUI convictions, the stakes were particularly high. Facing significant additional jail time and considerable public scrutiny, the client needed an attorney willing to look beyond the allegations and thoroughly investigate the evidence.
Senior Partner Steven L. Duckett, Jr. did exactly that. His examination of the Commonwealth's blood testing records revealed serious questions about the chain of custody, ultimately helping him negotiate a favorable resolution that significantly limited his client's additional jail time.
A Critical Discovery in the Blood Testing Records
DUI cases involving blood evidence can be scientifically and procedurally complex. The reliability of laboratory testing depends on more than the reported results. How a sample is collected, documented, transported, stored, and analyzed can all become important considerations when evaluating the evidence.
With more than 25 years of criminal defense experience, Steve has continued to advance his knowledge through specialized DUI education and training focused on forensic blood testing, laboratory procedures, and the scientific evidence used in DUI prosecutions.
That training played an important role in his approach to this case.
Rather than simply accepting the Commonwealth's reported test results, Steve subpoenaed records from the Virginia Department of Forensic Science (DFS) to examine how the client's blood sample had been handled.
What he discovered raised significant concerns about the chain of custody.
These questions created substantial evidentiary challenges for the prosecution and provided Steve with an opportunity to negotiate a considerably more favorable outcome for his client.
Criminal Defense Is About Protecting the Integrity of Our Justice System
This case attracted media attention, and we recognize that cases involving repeat DUI allegations can generate strong public reactions. Battlefield Law Group does not condone drinking and driving. We do, however, firmly believe in the constitutional protections afforded to every person accused of a crime.
Our criminal justice system is built on the presumption of innocence, and the Commonwealth bears the burden of proving guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. An arrest, an accusation, or even a person's prior criminal history does not relieve prosecutors of that responsibility.
Defense attorneys play an essential role in upholding these principles. Their responsibility is to examine the evidence, challenge deficiencies, protect their clients' constitutional rights, and hold the prosecution to its burden of proof.
In this case, the questions surrounding the blood sample's chain of custody presented a serious challenge to the Commonwealth's evidence. Steve's willingness to investigate those records helped change the direction of the case.
Accountability in our justice system must extend to everyone, including the prosecution.
Advanced DUI Training Makes a Difference
At Battlefield Law Group, we believe effective DUI defense requires more than familiarity with Virginia's DUI laws. It demands a working understanding of the science, testing procedures, and investigative methods behind the evidence.
Steve's continued education in forensic blood analysis and laboratory practices reflects our firm's commitment to building informed, trial-ready defenses. Our attorneys examine the unique circumstances of each case, pursue opportunities for mitigation and favorable negotiations, and are prepared to litigate when the evidence and circumstances warrant taking a case to court.
By identifying significant questions surrounding the blood sample's chain of custody, Steve was able to negotiate a favorable resolution that resulted in a sentence amounting to essentially time served, rather than the substantial additional incarceration his client was facing.